Thanksgiving-inspired sandwiches have become a beloved trend across New England, especially in Portland, combining all the best holiday flavors into one convenient meal. While most spots only offer these sandwiches seasonally, we think they should stick around all winter! If you’re in the mood for a quick taste of Thanksgiving, check out this list of Portland restaurants serving up these festive favorites!
NOTE: THESE SANDWICHES ARE SUBJECT TO AVAILABILITY
Po’ Boys and Pickles has solidified its reputation as a local favorite, consistently winning the title of Best Sandwich Spot in our Best of Awards year after year. Known for their creativity and bold flavors, they’ve crafted a unique twist on the classic Thanksgiving sandwich. Their Thanksgiving Po’ Boy features tender slow-roasted turkey, a zesty jalapeño-cranberry sauce, homemade stuffing, rich turkey gravy, and a creamy roasted garlic mayo!
Becky’s Diner is a Portland staple, serving up delicious meals from before sunrise to long after sunset. Known for their comfort food and hearty portions, they’ve put a standout twist on the classic Thanksgiving sandwich. Their version features crispy buttermilk fried turkey, savory sausage stuffing, and tangy cranberry mayonnaise, all perfectly nestled in a soft bulkie roll. It’s a flavorful creation that truly sets them apart and is not to be missed!
Cheese Louise has built a reputation for turning the humble grilled cheese into a culinary masterpiece, and their Gobble Gobbler is no exception. This creative twist on Thanksgiving flavors features oven-roasted turkey, flavorful stuffing, tangy cranberry sauce, rich gravy, and melted Swiss cheese, all perfectly layered on cinnamon cranberry sourdough. It’s a grilled cheese experience like no other—one bite, and you’ll see why it’s a must-try!
Dutch’s has become a go-to spot for both locals and visitors, celebrated for its mouthwatering breakfast and lunch offerings. Their Gobbler sandwich lives up to the hype, with house-roasted turkey, rich stuffing, creamy garlic aioli, and tangy cranberry sauce, all tucked into a warm, toasted dinner roll. It’s the perfect way to enjoy the tastes of Thanksgiving!
Tally’s Kitchen in Bayside is a popular spot for local professionals, known for their delicious wraps, salads, and flatbreads. What sets them apart on this list is their commitment to keeping the Thanksgiving spirit alive year-round. Their Pilgrim sandwich features roasted turkey, hearty stuffing, and cranberry mayonnaise, all perfectly layered on cranberry bread. It’s a festive favorite you can enjoy any time of the year!
Last but certainly not least is Market Street Eats, offering a delicious twist on Thanksgiving leftovers with their special sandwich available after the holiday. This post-Thanksgiving creation features house-roasted turkey, melted Havarti, sweet potato, stovetop stuffing, cranberry sauce, and crispy fried onions. If you’re still craving those classic holiday flavors, this sandwich is the perfect way to enjoy them all over again!
Did we miss one? Let us know—we’d be happy to include more options in our guide!
